Couche-Tard Not Expected To Renew Bid For Casey's

"We can't keep doing what we've always done and just keep tweaking to make it better. Sometimes, you've just got to change."

Sonja Hubbard, E-Z Mart, page 40

As of the third quarter of 2010, 28 percent of U.S. mobile subscribers now have smartphones — cell phones with operating systems resembling computers.

Source: The Nielsen Co.

Midwestern c-store chain likely to remain independent

Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. is not expected to rekindle its interest in Casey's General Stores now that the Iowa-based convenience store chain has broken off talks with Texas-based 7-Eleven Inc., analysts who have been following the saga told The Canadian Press.

Amid weeks of negotiations, 7-Eleven increased its cash offer by $3 per share to $43. That's compared to $38.50 per share that had been offered by Couche-Tard.

Couche-Tard, Canada's largest convenience store chain, threw in the towel Sept. 30, following a bruising six-month battle to acquire Casey's for $2 billion, the report noted.

Ben Brownlow, a Casey's analyst with Morgan, Keegan and Co., told The Canadian Press he wasn't surprised by Casey's rejection and doesn't believe Quebec-based Couche-Tard will stray from its disciplined acquisition strategy to top 7-Eleven's failed bid.

"The (Casey's) board and a majority of shareholders believe that the shares are worth north of $43, and I wouldn't expect Couche-Tard to pay that high a price," Brownlow said.

In fact, he said he believes the cost of 7-Eleven's offer was $45 per share when considering the $100 million in penalties associated with Casey's recapitalization. That's about the 12-month share price target of analysts, according to the report.

Irene Nattel, an analyst with Desjardins Securities, said Casey's rejection of $43 sends a clear message to other potential bidders that the board is unlikely to support any price below mid-$40s.

She had previously speculated that Couche-Tard could eventually mount a new challenge for Casey's once 7-Eleven walked away. Nattel said Casey's remains the "blue chip" among convenience store operators with robust gas and foodservice margins despite a sluggish economy.